Looking for color by Hex, RGB, CMYK, or Lab?

Color Image

Actual color may vary from on-screen representation. Please view a physical color swatch or material sample to confirm your color choice prior to purchase.

Fast Shipping

70% of Orders Ship within 3 Business Days.

Ready to purchase? Select your options in the 4 steps below.

Step 1: Select Paint Type / Application

Spray, OEM, Bottles and Pens

House and Wall Paint

Epoxy, Urethane, and Colorant Concentrate


A match of PlyGem Mastic Brown (59) is a muted, medium-dark brown with a soft gray cast and a slightly warm undertone. It reads as a low-chroma exterior brown rather than a bright or reddish brown, so the color stays subdued and close to neutral.

For touch-up after shipping, installation, field cutting, or service work, use an Original Material Match product when the job is on factory-finished building materials because it includes a sheen match. MyPerfectColor spray paint matched to this color can also be used on replacement siding pieces, trim boards, vent covers, shutter parts, fascia details, gutter components, brackets, fastener caps, and other ancillary exterior parts that need to coordinate with existing PlyGem Mastic siding.

Because this is a dark, low-chroma brown, the substrate can still influence the result. Lighter surfaces or rough cut edges may need careful coverage to avoid show-through, and gloss level, texture, and embossing can make a matched color read differently after application. Only Original Material Match should be used for direct touch-up on factory-finished material; other product types are better suited to separate parts or broader repainting where a sheen-matched touch-up is not the goal.

On aged or weathered installed material, a correct brand color reference may still sit beside fading, chalking, or batch variation. In those cases, matching an existing part or approved sample can be more reliable than assuming a fresh repair will disappear into the surrounding surface.

Similar colors:

Peppercorn (Pe)
Woodland Retreat (Vinyl)
Winestone (58)

Product Data

About PlyGem Mastic Paint Colors

The PlyGem Mastic® brands offer a wide selection of quality building products that includes windows, patio doors, siding, stone veneer, fences and railings. We are proud to match their colors in paint to assist with your touch up needs.

Matching PlyGem Mastic Paint Colors

MyPerfectColor is able match all of the PlyGem Mastic paint colors so you can find and enjoy the colors you love. MyPerfectColor uses its expert capabilities to recreate the original PlyGem Mastic color by matching the original PlyGem Mastic color books and swatches.

The colors shown on this website are computer video simulations of the PlyGem Mastic Color and may not match PlyGem Mastic Color standards. Refer to PlyGem Mastic Publications to obtain the accurate color. Please know that MyPerfectColor is matching the original PlyGem Mastic color. If you intend to touch up paint that has been on your walls for years, know that your color has undoubtedly changed from the original due to exposure to light and age and the new paint may not match. You will achieve best results by re-coating the entire surface.

If you need more assistance, please feel free to contact us and one of our expert staff would be happy to help.

Frequently Asked Questions About Match of PlyGem Mastic® Brown (59) *

Can I use MyPerfectColor paint matched to PlyGem Mastic Brown (59) for touch up after shipping damage, installation damage, or field work?

Yes, if you are doing direct touch up on a factory-finished building material, choose the MyPerfectColor product option that explicitly says Original Material Match for PlyGem Mastic Brown (59). That option is the one intended for touch up because it includes a sheen match.

If the repair is on a replacement part or another separate piece, other MyPerfectColor formats may be appropriate, but they should not be treated as the direct touch-up choice for a factory-finished surface.

Will PlyGem Mastic Brown (59) match an older installed siding surface, or only the original factory color reference?

A match of PlyGem Mastic Brown (59) is a factory color reference, so it gives you the correct starting point for the color match. An older installed surface can still read differently because of sun exposure, weathering, chalking, sheen change, texture, and batch variation.

If the surrounding siding is aged or highly visible, do not assume the repair will blend perfectly just because the color reference is right. In those cases, an existing-part or site-specific sample is often the safer reference.

Which MyPerfectColor format should I order for PlyGem Mastic Brown (59) if I need direct touch up versus a replacement part?

For direct touch up on PlyGem Mastic Brown (59), order the product option that says Original Material Match. That is the correct choice because it includes a sheen match for factory-finished building materials.

Water-based housepaint, urethane, and epoxy can still be color-matched options, but they are better suited to separate parts, accessories, or broader repainting jobs. They should not be treated as the direct touch-up choice for a factory-finished surface.

Is PlyGem Mastic Brown (59) the right reference for siding, trim, and nearby exterior parts that need to blend?

Yes. A match of PlyGem Mastic Brown (59) is a siding-related building-material color reference, so it is useful when you need a matched paint for siding, trim, or nearby exterior parts that must coordinate with the factory finish.

This can apply to replacement boards, trim pieces, soffit, fascia, gutters, flashings, shutters, or similar accessories when the goal is to blend a paintable part with nearby PlyGem Mastic siding materials.

For PlyGem Mastic Brown (59), should I match the brand color or send an existing part or factory sample?

If the installed PlyGem Mastic Brown (59) material has aged, or if the repair is highly visible, a sample or existing part is often the better reference than the nominal color name alone. That helps account for weathering, sheen, texture, and lot variation.

Use the brand color reference when you are matching a known factory color, but switch to an existing part or factory sample when the project has tight approval limits or the surrounding surface has changed over time.

How quickly will I receive my paint matched to PlyGem Mastic Brown (59)?
All paint is custom-made to order. While most orders ship within 48 hours, the lead-time for paint made to match PlyGem Mastic Brown (59) depends on the type of paint needed. Interior and exterior house paints usually ship within 1 to 3 business days, while custom spray paint typically takes 3-5 business days to ship. The transit time depends on your location and the shipping method you choose. If your need is immediate, select Expedited Production during checkout. Most expedited production orders ship within 24 hours on business days. Please contact MyPerfectColor if you are concerned about a specific deadline. We do our best to make sure you get your paint on time. Learn more about paint lead times at MyPerfectColor.
Can I use this PlyGem Mastic Brown (59) paint to touch up my PlyGem Mastic materials?

It depends. MyPerfectColor matches the color of the PlyGem Mastic Brown (59) but may not match the sheen. If you see Custom Sheen as a sheen option, this means we also match the sheen of the material, otherwise you would need to pick the closest sheen available. However, keep in mind that our version of the PlyGem Mastic Brown (59) is based on matching an official PlyGem Mastic color sample. The color and sheen of your specific PlyGem Mastic parts may vary. If your material is not new and has been exposed to the weather, then it is likely that the color has changed over time. MyPerfectColor samples not been exposed to sunlight and weather. If you need a touch up application, you may need to send us a part so we can create a touch up solution precisely matching the current color and sheen of your specific materials.

Learn more about our color matching service.

What are the RGB, HEX and LRV values for PlyGem Mastic Brown (59)?
The RGB values for PlyGem Mastic Brown (59) are 78, 70, 67 and the HEX code is #4E4643. The LRV for PlyGem Mastic Brown (59) is 6.44. The LRV stands for Light Reflectance Value and measures the percentage of light that a color reflects. Learn more about Light Reflectance Values and using RGB and Hex codes for paint.
What paint type is used to make spray paint matched to PlyGem Mastic Brown (59)? And how many spray cans do I need?

MyPerfectColor uses an acrylic enamel which is a fast-drying durable coating suitable for interior or exterior use. MyPerfectColor custom spray paint matched to PlyGem Mastic Brown (59) enables you to conveniently achieve a professional spray-smooth finish in any color in any sheen. It sticks well to most surfaces including metal, plastics, powder-coatings, cabinets and primed or previously painted wood.

The MyPerfectColor 11oz spray will cover about 20 square feet per coat. Keep in mind that it is difficult to gauge spray paint need as the coverage is highly dependent on how it is applied. Learn more about how spray paint works at MyPerfectColor.

Can I paint gutters to match my PlyGem Mastic siding?
Absolutely. You can use the MyPerfectColor spray paint matching the PlyGem Mastic Brown (59) to paint your gutters to match your siding. The spray paint will enable you to conveniently achieve a spray smooth finish. Learn more about custom spray paint.
Can you paint PlyGem Mastic siding with PlyGem Mastic Brown (59)?

MyPerfectColor Paint matching the PlyGem Mastic Brown (59) can be used to paint siding and any other items you'd like to blend into your exterior such as windows, doors, lights, pipes, gutters and vents. Many types of paint are available with no minimum order quantities. MyPerfectColor offers spray paint, paint pens, touch up bottles, water-based acrylics, epoxies, urethanes and a variety of other paints. The best paint for painting siding is exterior house paint (usually low lustre sheen). Spray paint works great for windows, doors, lights, pipes, vents and more.

Paint can be purchased by choosing the paint type above. Contact MyPerfectColor support if you have specific questions about the best paint to use for your project.

How does MyPerfectColor match the PlyGem Mastic Brown (59)?

MyPerfectColor has the original PlyGem Mastic color samples. A sample of the PlyGem Mastic Brown (59) you are looking for is in our library. We are able to make paint and verify that it matches the original.

Please note that if your existing materials are not new and you are trying to touch up, they will have aged and are likely different now than they were when new. MyPerfectColor will be sending paint matching the sample at our facility which has not aged the same as your materials and may also be different due to other factors such as variations in manufacturing processes. If your match is critical, you may consider sending a part of your materials for precise color matching. Learn more about our color matching services.

Does paint matched to PlyGem Mastic Brown (59) need primer if I am painting outside?
The need for primer for Brown (59) depends on the type of paint, the substrate being painted and where it will be located. See our Primer Selection Table to see what primer you might need and learn more about when you might need a primer. Most people don't use a primer for a touch up paint application, but a primer may improve adhesion and is typically recommended for exterior applications.