Benjamin Moore Paint Sale - Ultra Spec 500 Flat Only $29.87/Gal
FREE SHIPPING on orders over $50
Excludes custom color spray paint and some other products

Fireplace paint color

Our contractor is almost done with our remodel, but we are stuck on what to paint the living room fireplace wood form around the light brown swirl tile & hearth. The W2W carpet is dark brown. The walls are barely off-white, and the trim is green-gray. We had the fireplace painted a browner than honey-mustard which goes with the rest of the fireplace but not the trim. Do you have any suggestions about what colors to look at for the fireplace? Thanks!


By any chance can you attach a photograph of of your fire place? Need to see the colors in more detail since there are different undertones of brown. My recommendation would be to pull the lighter tint out of the light brown swirl tile. In translation the wood form needs to be painted in a tint/white, reason being anything with tile it is best to pull out the lightest color, so there will be no competition against other colors on your fireplace. The tile will be at the forefront which I am sure is a beautiful accent piece for your room. As with the trim go with a green. The gray in the green could be causing friction with other colors, stick to an earthy green.

Happy to be of assistance.


Color Tools

I should clarify...the green-gray trim which you can see around the windows is used throughout the house including the living and dining rooms which are separated by a wide archway to make up half the main floor. We like the window trim and background colors, just not in love with the fireplace color. The wood framed map on top of the mantle in picture #3 makes me think that some sort of burgundy might work. We prefer not to paint the fireplace the same color as the trim or the background. House built in 1919 and is in an urban environment. Please let me know if you any more information and thank you for your vision. Brad

Hi Brad,

From my understanding you had pictures attached? I could not locate any attached photos in the system. Can you try loading photographs again? Photographs have to appear above this question.

Thank you,


Hi - I attached them again. The only place I see on the page to Add images is below the last response.

Shared photos

Shared photos

Hi Brad,

For some reason I have not been able to locate your photographs. Confused, can you please try again. When you clicked on add images afterwards did you select the submit icon? For some reason I am not seeing anything on my screen.


Hi Brad,

Finally received your photographs this morning. Here are some suggestions to consider, you have conflicting colors with warm and cool undertones this is why the fireplace color is not working in your living area. One option is to paint the trim a color with warm undertones and keep the fireplace in harmony due to the fact the fire place has warm under toned tiles. if you prefer the trim color, in my opinion your fireplace is too dark with your dark carpet. A room needs to have visual contrast in defining the space. Dark floors and fireplace does not work. There are options to look at in keeping your preferred trim color and carpet.

One option is to go with a medium toned green for fire place and mantel. The other one is to paint your fireplace white with warm undertones pulling out the warmth of brown swirls. These colors should be safe. Please note lighting conditions can influence how a color reflects; therefore. several whites are attached for you to decide which one works best. Pull out the undertones of white in your tile.

Option #1 Color for Fire Place

White Fire Place

White Flour SW7101

Nice White SW

Everyday White SW6077

Simple White SW

Option #2 Color for Fire Place

Green #1 Body

Sage Wisdom CSP-775

Green #2 Mantel

Sage Brush CSP-770

Please note greens look grayer on screen versus live color on sample board.
Also the undertones in the whites are more pronounced as compared to a live swatch.

I hope this works out.


Option #2

For your reference, these are the photos submitted. I'm uploading them for you.

Sorry, the photos simply won't upload for some reason. Look like Mary has given some great suggestions for your fireplace area.

Add images